Scope gaps between trade packages: where commercial projects lose time and money
On a commercial project, most work is clearly owned by one trade. The problems tend to sit in the small items between trades, where each package assumes the other one has it covered. These scope gaps rarely show up at tender. They show up on site, late, as variations and delays.
Where the gaps usually are
The same interfaces cause trouble on project after project:
- Penetrations through walls, floors and ceilings, and who seals them.
- Noggings and supports for fixtures, joinery and services installed by others.
- Patching and making good after services trades.
- Sealants and caulking at junctions between different materials.
- Access panels in walls and ceilings.
- Set-out, and who checks it before work starts.
- Protection of finished work, and cleaning.
- Hoisting, material handling and rubbish removal.
None of these is large on its own. Together they can add up to a significant part of a project's variations.
Why they happen
Trade packages are usually scoped from the drawings and specification section for that trade. Each subcontractor prices what is shown in their section and lists what they have excluded.
When the exclusions from one package are not checked against the inclusions of the next, the gap between them belongs to nobody. It stays hidden until the work reaches that point on site.
What they cost
A gap found on site costs more than the same item priced at tender. It is priced as a variation, often under time pressure, with a crew waiting. It can hold up following trades, and it tends to arrive at the end of the job when the budget and the program have the least room.
There is also a cost in the working relationship. Disputes over who owns a small item take time away from finishing the building.
How head contractors can close them early
- Compare the exclusions of each tender against the inclusions of the trades around it.
- Use a simple scope matrix for the common interfaces, with one owner named against each item.
- Raise the interfaces at the prelet meeting, before the subcontract is signed.
- Ask each subcontractor what they are assuming others will do.
- Record the answers in the subcontract scope, not in an email trail.
A scope gap closed before award is a line in a subcontract. The same gap found on site is a variation, a delay and an argument.
This article is general information only. It is not engineering, design, legal or other professional advice, and it does not take into account the requirements of any particular project. Requirements vary between projects and between Queensland, New South Wales and other jurisdictions. Always refer to the project documentation, the relevant codes and standards, manufacturers' tested system details and suitably qualified consultants. Echo Construction Group Pty Ltd accepts no liability for any loss arising from reliance on this information.