Supply and install or labour only: what changes for the head contractor
Carpentry and linings packages are usually let one of two ways. Under supply and install, the subcontractor provides the materials and the labour. Under labour only, the head contractor buys the materials and the subcontractor installs them.
The rates look very different on a tender comparison, but the two prices are not measuring the same thing. The real difference is who carries which risk.
Who carries the quantities
Under supply and install, the subcontractor measures the job, orders the materials and wears the waste. If the take-off is short, that is the subcontractor's problem.
Under labour only, the quantities sit with the head contractor. Under-ordering stops work. Over-ordering leaves stock on site that has been paid for and has to be stored, moved or returned.
Who carries the lead times
Materials arriving late is one of the most common reasons a package stalls. Under supply and install, procurement and delivery are the subcontractor's responsibility, and the program can be held against one party.
Under labour only, a late delivery from the head contractor's supplier can leave an installation crew standing. That standing time usually becomes a cost discussion.
Who handles the materials on site
Someone has to receive deliveries, check them, store them out of the weather and get them to the work face. Under supply and install, that is normally inside the package. Under labour only, it needs to be allowed for somewhere, whether in the head contractor's site team, the hoisting plan or the subcontract scope.
Who answers for a defect
When one party supplies and installs, there is a single point of responsibility if something fails. When the materials come from one party and the workmanship from another, a defect can turn into a question of which one caused it.
That question is easier to answer when the split of responsibility is written down before work starts.
Where each approach tends to suit
Supply and install tends to suit packages where the head contractor wants one party accountable for quantity, delivery, installation and defects.
Labour only tends to suit head contractors who have strong supplier arrangements, the site resources to manage deliveries and storage, and a clear view of the quantities.
What to make clear either way
- Who measures and orders, and who carries waste.
- Who receives, stores and moves materials on site.
- What happens to cost and program if materials arrive late.
- Who is responsible for material defects and who for workmanship.
- What is included in the rate and what is not.
Neither approach is better in general. The right one depends on where the head contractor wants the risk to sit, and on both parties understanding that before the package is let.
This article is general information only. It is not engineering, design, legal or other professional advice, and it does not take into account the requirements of any particular project. Requirements vary between projects and between Queensland, New South Wales and other jurisdictions. Always refer to the project documentation, the relevant codes and standards, manufacturers' tested system details and suitably qualified consultants. Echo Construction Group Pty Ltd accepts no liability for any loss arising from reliance on this information.